The Ideal Diamond for Luxury Settings
Revitalize your cherished jewelry with the expertise of our Master Jewelers and Professional Stone Sourcing team. Restore its brilliance with our diamond replacement services!
Our Diamond Replacement Services Include

Pricing Dependent on Gemstone
The Trusted Online Mail-In Process for Diamond Replacement Services Services
With locations on the east and west coast, we have the expertise to provide gemstone resetting services, with specialists equipped and skilled to handle your diamond jewelry with such precision.
How Our Process Works
Receive Your Restored Item
Professional Services For Your Diamond Jewelry
Replace Your Gemstone with the Perfect Diamond
Experience our renowned diamond replacement services, skillfully performed by our Master Jewelers to seamlessly restore your jewelry, leaving no trace of intervention.
Professional Stone Sourcing: Our team specializes in sourcing every type of diamond, from round-brilliant to princess cuts, ensuring each gem meets the unique needs of your treasured jewelry. We pay close attention to even the smallest details to replace your sapphires with stones of the highest quality, including invisible settings.
Thoughtful Selection: At My Jewelry Repair, we prioritize finding the perfect diamond to complement your jewelry, ensuring a seamless match with the existing setting. The pricing of our sapphire replacement service reflects the service and caliber of gemstone sourced, as well as any possible damage to the setting or the item in general.
We are proud members of the
Our team includes gemologists certified by
Sending in Your Diamond Jewelry to Repair
Alternative Gemstone Options to Diamonds
We offer a variety of choices for finding the perfect match, including popular alternatives like Moissanites, White Topazes, and Lab-Created Diamonds. These options are favored for their durability, affordability, and eco-friendliness. If you’re interested in other gemstones like Sapphires, Rubies, or Emeralds, please visit our Gemstone Replacement service page for more details.
To learn more about the history and proper maintenance for your diamonds, visit our Ultimate Diamond Guide for more information!

We offer free standard shipping* and many additional options of insurance plans to keep your precious package safe.
*Partnered Stores/Manufacturers may have their own requirements for shipping and/or insurance specifications.
Providing Premier Setting Services
State-Of-The-Art Setting Lab
Our Custom Setting Lab have been meticulously designed for our Master Craftsmen. It provides an ideal environment to concentrate on perfecting each gemstone setting. This level of dedication and detail is what our premier manufacturing partners expect from us.
Our pristine labs boast state-of-the-art jeweler benches, the finest tools, and high-tech microscopes, all geared toward creating your perfect piece.
The blend of our Master Jewelers’ expertise, the precision tools at their disposal, and years of experience empower us to deliver the highest quality setting services right to your doorstep!
Have Questions?
How Do You Replace a Missing Diamond?
- The process of a Diamond Replacement is simple enough, yet requires trained eyes to be able to make a flawless switch. We aim to leave no trace of our work, which means not only will your setting be perfected, but the diamond we choose will complete your jewelry piece effortlessly.
- First, we begin by evaluating your item. In the case of a missing diamond(s), we search for a perfect match to replace the missing gem(s). Once the necessary materials have been acquired, we then complete the Diamond Replacement process by masterfully setting each of the stones. Finishing the service with a clean and polish that will leave your item looking as beautiful as the day you got it.
Who Does Diamond Replacements & Where Do I Go to Get It Done?
- A Diamond Replacement service requires the expertise of a master jeweler and a Professional Stone Sourcing team. At My Jewelry Repair, we have both of these necessary elements in order to offer the highest caliber of diamond replacement.
- With us, you don’t have to go anywhere! Our online, contactless service makes it possible to replace your diamond all from the comfort of your home!
How Much Does a Diamond Replacement Cost?
- The price of a Diamond Replacement varies depending on the price of the new diamond(s), as well as the amount of damage, etc.
- For more information regarding the pricing of our jewelry repair services, feel free to check out our Pricing page.
What Standard of Diamonds Does My Jewelry Repair Use?
- At My Jewelry Repair, the standard of diamond we use varies depending on the standard of diamond we are replacing. If there is not a request for a specific caliber of diamond, we will find one that matches the quality of your diamond perfectly. Of course, if you wish to increase the quality or lower the quality of your diamond, those changes can be accommodated upon request.
- For alternative gemstone options, as well as more information regarding the Professional Sourcing of our diamonds/gemstones, please visit our Gemstone Replacement service page
How Does Diamond Replacement Online Work?
You Never Have to Leave Your Home with Our Online Jewelry Repair Process!
- Create your order.
- Print your shipping label and order slip.
- Choose your insurance, pack your repair(s).
- My Jewelry Repair provides step-by-step instructions for safe packaging and travel. All you have to do from there is schedule USPS courier pickup if you don’t want to leave your home, or drop-off (with your nearest USPS location). Tracking included for safe arrival and transparency.
You’ll never have to navigate a baffling mall layout again, looking for a ‘quick’ repair that takes forever. All you have to do is put the item in the mail and we’ll have your perfected item back to you in no time!
How Long Does a Diamond Replacement Service Typically Take?
- On average, a Diamond Replacement repair takes 2-4 business days, but the timeline will vary depending on numerous factors, such as the required labor, the extent of the damage, the receiving of necessary gemstones/materials, etc.
- For more information regarding the timeline of your Diamond Replacement service, please refer to our Standard Timelines page.
You Have Questions, We Have Answers!
- If you have any questions regarding our Diamond Replacement service, please feel free to Contact Us. We are more than happy to answer any questions or discuss any concerns you may have!
Ready to Restore Your Diamond Jewelry?
“Searched All Over Russia/Ukraine for the Parts Needed”
This particular work order took over a year to fully complete, with the watch being sent back three times for all the work to be done properly. I do understand that this was harder project given that it’s a vintage Russian movement, but I can’t tell you enough how much
…
This particular work order took over a year to fully complete, with the watch being sent back three times for all the work to be done properly. I do understand that this was harder project given that it’s a vintage Russian movement, but I can’t tell you enough how much it meant that you searched all over Russia/Ukraine for the parts needed to complete the work. The watch is running absolutely amazing and can’t believe how good it is running. It’s truly a centerpiece to my vintage watch collection and I absolutely love it. Thanks again for all the hard work and time you put into it and that’s what prompted this message. I do believe in acknowledging hard work and this is truly wonderful. Thank you again and keep up the good work.
Read more ““Searched All Over Russia/Ukraine for the Parts Needed””
I feel like I have found a treasure
THANK YOU for restoring my Montana Silversmiths Earrings back to their original condition! You did an awesome job, and, they are as beautiful now as when I purchased them over 25 years ago! I called Montana Silversmiths and spoke with Sheila Green in Customer Service, and gave her your contact
…
THANK YOU for restoring my Montana Silversmiths Earrings back to their original condition! You did an awesome job, and, they are as beautiful now as when I purchased them over 25 years ago! I called Montana Silversmiths and spoke with Sheila Green in Customer Service, and gave her your contact information so that they can now direct their customers directly to you when they need something reconditioned. I feel like I have found a treasure in knowing that you can repair and restore everything from inexpensive pieces to very valuable pieces. You can bet that I will be sending more business your way!
Read more “I feel like I have found a treasure”
Jennifer Greene
They did a beautiful job on the exterior cleaning and polish
Sent my automatic watch to these folks for repair as it was no longer keeping accurate time, they assessed the watch for needed repairs and sent me the estimate which I approved. About three weeks later I received a email stating that my watch had shipped, they provide a tracking
…
Sent my automatic watch to these folks for repair as it was no longer keeping accurate time, they assessed the watch for needed repairs and sent me the estimate which I approved.
About three weeks later I received a email stating that my watch had shipped, they provide a tracking number that I might keep a track of it, upon receiving the watch I inspected it and have to say that they did a beautiful job on the exterior cleaning and polish plus they replaced the clasp, I can only assume that the work done to the movement is of equal quality and detail this will be born out over time as I see how the accuracy is.
They also provided the pressure test ticket in the return package.
I would recommend this company if you have need of jewelry repair.
Read more “They did a beautiful job on the exterior cleaning and polish”
Gordon M.